
Do girls and boys still dream of ponies and horses? I lived and almost breathed horses--reading stories, collecting figurines, and drawing pictures, without a hope of ever having a horse. For those who have ever loved horses in real life or imagination, here are two books based on true stories--a new one and a classic that hasn't lost its power. Susan Jeffers, author and illustrator of the picture book
My Chincoteague Pony, was inspired at the age of seven by Marguerite Henry's
Misty of Chincoteague. Ms. Jeffers even includes a letter from Ms. Henry in My Chincoteague Pony, bringing everything full circle.
Misty of Chincoteague, the 1947 story of Paul and Maureen Beebe, is as dramatic as the annual round-up and running of the wild ponies from Assateague to Chincoteague Islands, not far from Virginia Beach. The brief but vivid backstory of a Spanish galleon carrying ponies to the New World conveys to elementary and middle school readers the fear and excitement of the ponies as they are tossed in the ocean, then on the shore to fend for themselves. Next, we meet the twentieth-century brother and sister who do live and breathe ponies and can hardly wait to capture and purchase one of their own. Now that Paul is old enough to ride on Pony Penning Day, dreams grow into plans, negotiations with Grandpa and Grandma Beebe, work and more work to earn enough money for the mysterious mare called the Phantom. But getting a pony is only the beginning of a new chapter. We ride with Maureen and Paul through hopes and disappointments, adventures, lessons, and surprises, finding that there are some things we can change, but some areas where nature prevails.
A good story for younger lovers of stories and horses,
My Chincoteague Pony is updated and simplified, but reflects many elements of its predecessor. The living history, the wildness of the grown ponies, the appeal of the foals—all populate the imagination of Julie, who works as hard as Paul and Maureen to get her own pony, only to come up short. But when an unexpected event and the kindness of strangers intervene to make Julie’s dream come true, she finds out not only that persistence pays off, but that joy can be multiplied by passing it on.

Each book resonates with its own time and place, as well as its audience. The very different illustrations fully complement each story. Illustrator Wesley Dennis’ wild ponies as well as Maureen and Paul’s exploits are beautifully rendered in black and white, while Susan Jeffers’ work brings her picture book to life, from the sparkly cover of My Chincoteague Pony to Julie’s joy in the end. Marguerite Henry’s references to a pony whickering “at the sound of Man’s voice,” Grandpa’s dialect and bristly ears, and the seemingly small amount of money earned for an afternoon of hard work help make Misty of Chincoteague the finest sort of historical novel. We can discuss differences between our world and that of the book, but we also grasp instinctively the timeless experiences of nature and human nature, emotions and relationships--including the ups and downs of a brother and sister together.
In addition to these wonderful reads, you can also find in the VBPL catalog other favorite horse stories, from Walter Farley’s
The Black Stallion and Anna Sewell’s
Black Beauty, to the present-day Pony Pals and Thoroughbred series. Nonfiction brings dreams to life with photographs and facts. Check out
The Chincoteague Pony by Charlotte Wilcox and many other nonfiction books written for children about horses of various kinds. There’s also the homegrown
Chessy: The Story of a Police Horse in Virginia Beach who may have had his own dreams.